Poblano Pepper Substitute: Recipe Options

  • By: Ann Williams
  • Time to read: 5 min.

Poblano Pepper Substitute

When a recipe calls for poblano peppers, but you can’t find them in your local grocery store or want to try something different, we have you covered with poblano pepper substitutes.

There are several fantastic poblano pepper alternatives that can add a similar depth of flavor and mild heat to your dishes. Whether you’re making stuffed peppers, sauces, or soups, these options are sure to please your taste buds.


What Is A Substitute For Poblano Pepper?

  1. Anaheim Peppers: Anaheim peppers are a close relative to poblanos and offer a comparable mild heat. They can be used in most recipes that call for poblano peppers.
  2. Cubanelle Peppers: Cubanelle peppers are another excellent substitute, especially if you prefer a milder option. They have a slightly sweet taste and work well in various dishes.
  3. Green Bell Peppers: For a readily available and milder substitute, green bell peppers can do the trick. While not as spicy as poblanos, they add a pleasant crunch to your recipes.
  4. New Mexico Peppers (Hatch Chiles): If you desire a bit more heat, New Mexico peppers, also known as Hatch chiles, can be a suitable replacement for poblanos.
  5. Italian Frying Peppers: These peppers are flavorful and mildly spicy, making them a good alternative for poblanos in many dishes.
  6. Cubanella Peppers: Cubanella peppers are sweet and mildly spicy, making them an excellent substitute for poblanos, especially in salads and stir-fries.



Substitution for poblano pepper

What is a poblano pepper?

A poblano pepper is a large, dark green chili pepper with a mild to medium level of spiciness. It is commonly used in Mexican cuisine and has a distinctive flavor profile.

You might also be interested in this article – Guajillo Chili Substitute


Is poblano pepper the same as Capsicum?

Yes, poblano pepper belongs to the Capsicum genus, which includes various types of peppers such as bell peppers, jalapenos, and cayenne peppers.


Is poblano similar to jalapeno?

While poblano peppers and jalapenos are both chili peppers, they have notable differences. Poblano peppers are larger, milder, and have a more earthy flavor, while jalapenos are smaller, spicier, and have a slightly grassy taste.


Can I substitute green chilies for poblano peppers?

Yes, you can use green chilies as a substitute for poblano peppers in recipes. However, keep in mind that green chilies are typically spicier than poblanos, so adjust the quantity based on your desired level of heat.


Are poblano peppers very spicy?

No, poblano peppers are not very spicy. They generally have a mild to medium heat level, ranging from 1,000 to 2,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU), making them much milder than jalapenos.


Is a poblano pepper hotter than a bell pepper?

Yes, a poblano pepper is hotter than a bell pepper. While both are considered mild peppers, poblanos have a slight kick to them, whereas bell peppers have no spiciness at all.


What does a poblano pepper taste like?

Poblano peppers have a rich, earthy flavor with a mild level of spiciness. Some describe their taste as slightly sweet with hints of berry and herbaceous notes.


What is chili poblano in English?

Chili poblano in English is often referred to as a “poblano pepper.” The terms are used interchangeably to describe the same chili variety.


Are poblano peppers hotter than green peppers?

Yes, poblano peppers are hotter than green bell peppers. While both are considered mild, poblanos have a mild to medium spiciness, whereas green bell peppers have no heat at all.


What is the difference between poblano peppers and green peppers?

The main difference between poblano peppers and green bell peppers lies in their spiciness. Poblano peppers have a mild to medium heat level, while green bell peppers are entirely non-spicy.


Can you make poblano peppers less spicy?

Yes, you can make poblano peppers less spicy by removing the seeds and inner membrane, where most of the heat is concentrated.

Roasting or cooking the peppers can also mellow their spiciness.


Do poblano peppers get less hot when cooked?

Yes, cooking poblano peppers can reduce their spiciness. The heat from the peppers may dissipate during the cooking process, resulting in a milder taste.


Which is milder, poblano, or jalapeno?

Poblano peppers are milder than jalapenos. Poblanos typically have a mild to medium level of spiciness, while jalapenos are moderately hot.


Is poblano spicier than habanero?

No, poblano peppers are much milder than habanero peppers. Habaneros are significantly spicier and can be up to 100 times hotter than poblano peppers.


Do you have to remove the skin from poblano peppers?

Poblano Pepper

Removing the skin from poblano peppers is not always necessary but is often done to enhance the texture and presentation of certain dishes, such as chile rellenos.


Are poblano peppers hot without the seeds?

Poblano peppers are milder without the seeds since most of the heat is concentrated in the seeds and inner membrane. Removing the seeds can make the peppers less spicy.


Should you wear gloves when cutting poblano peppers?

Wearing gloves when cutting poblano peppers is recommended, especially if you have sensitive skin or are dealing with a large quantity of peppers. It helps prevent the transfer of capsaicin (the compound responsible for the spiciness) to your skin, which can cause irritation.


What is the easiest way to get the skin off a poblano pepper?

The easiest way to remove the skin from poblano peppers is to roast them over an open flame or under the broiler until the skin blackens and blisters. Then, place the roasted peppers in a sealed container or plastic bag for a few minutes. The steam will help loosen the skin, making it easier to peel off.


Why do people peel poblano peppers?

Peeling poblano peppers after roasting enhances the texture and flavor of dishes. It removes the tough outer skin, leaving behind tender and smoky-flavored flesh that adds a delicious dimension to various recipes.


What is the difference between a chile relleno and chile poblano?

A chile relleno is a stuffed pepper dish made with poblano peppers. Poblano peppers are used as the base to hold the filling, which is typically cheese or meat. The name “chile poblano” refers to the specific type of pepper used in the dish.


How do you prepare poblano peppers?

Poblano peppers can be prepared in various ways, such as roasting, stuffing, or chopping for use in recipes. Before using them, it is common to roast or char the peppers to enhance their flavor and texture.

After roasting, the skin can be peeled off, and the seeds and inner membrane can be removed to reduce spiciness, if desired.

Poblano peppers can then be used in a wide range of dishes to add a delicious and mildly spicy kick.



While poblanos are undoubtedly a unique and delicious pepper, the world of substitutes opens up a range of culinary possibilities. W

Whether you opt for the similar heat of Anaheim peppers or the mild sweetness of Cubanelle peppers, each substitute brings its own charm to the table. So, don’t hesitate to experiment and explore these alternatives in your recipes. With these poblano pepper substitutes, you can savor delightful flavors in your dishes, no matter what’s available in your pantry.

Happy cooking!


Extra Reading And Resources

Mustard Substitute: Delicious Alternatives For Your Recipes

Sumac Spice Substitute